What C:N ratios in soil particle-size fractions really say: N is preferentially sorbed by clays over organic C

Abstract

Factors affecting soil organic carbon (SOC) retention in the tropics are relatively well known, but this is not the case for N retention and thus C:N ratios, a common proxy for organic matter stability. Recent data suggest that SOC and N concentrations vary with climate, whereas soil C:N ratios depend on particle-size fractions contents. However, such knowledge is still incipient for tropical soils, native vegetations and deeper soil layers, which are critical to understand how land use and climate change affect C and N fluxes. We assessed SOC, N and C:N ratios in bulk soils and sand, silt and clay fractions, and their correlations with other soil properties under native tropical forests in the highlands near Lavras, Brazil. Soil samples were collected to 1-m depth in soils of contrasting texture and mineralogy, formed on quartzite, sericite-schist, gabbro, itabirite, ironstone, meta-limestone, gneiss, and phyllite. Mean SOC and N concentrations were generally high, whereas mean soil C:N ratios varied from 9.5 to 18.7 among parent materials, and only in three soils C:N ratios varied considerably with depth. Enrichment factors (EFs) were generally < 1 in the sand and silt fractions for SOC and especially N. Conversely, EFs for clay were mostly > 1 for SOC and even higher (up to 6.58) for N. Such trend indicates that SOC and N are concentrated in clays, and more importantly, that N sorption is favored compared with SOC, and likely dependent on clay mineralogy. Soil C:N ratios decreased with increasing values of exchangeable bases, due to higher N in the most fertile soils, suggesting that a mechanism of R-NH3+ cationic sorption is likely involved. Our results suggest that soil N is a critical component of the overall stabilization of soil organic matter onto clays of tropical soils, deserving further investigation also under temperate climate and other zones.